These tires have met or exceeded all expectations. I do a lot of highway commuting and these tires are as quiet and comfortable as I could hope for on a small car. Fuel mileage using this tire is slightly better than previous tires, but I don't see any huge savings at the pump. I have between 7 and 8/32nds of tread left, so I expect to get around 75,000 miles from this set. Dry performance is what I expect from an all-season, and rain performance is good. I use a dedicated snow tire (Blizzak) for the majority of the winter, but these tires have seen snow a few times. They are just as good as the snow tires on light snow and plowed roads, but I prefer the snow tires in deep snow and ice.
Overall a good all-around tire for commuting. If your commute includes icy conditions, either be extra cautious or swap to a dedicated snow tire (but that is advice I'd give to anyone on an all-season tire).