Goodyear vs. Michelin Truck Tire Comparison

Thursday, May 16, 2013 by Ben Rooney

In the first installment of my Goodyear versus Michelin comparison, I focused on car tires. Now, let's take a look at the truck and SUV tires offered by these two heavyweights of the tire industry.

Category: Crossover/SUV Touring All-Season

Contenders: Goodyear Assurance CS TripleTred All-Season vs. Michelin Latitude Tour

Verdict: Goodyear wins this close match-up with superior traction in wet and wintry weather. The same aggressive tread that helps it gain better traction in the worst weather conditions comes with a trade-off in ride and noise comfort. Customers who value a luxury ride and do most of their driving in moderate climates may find that the Michelin suits them better.

Category: Highway All-Season

Contenders: Goodyear Wrangler RT/S vs. Michelin LTX M/S2

Verdict: The Michelin LTX M/S2 wins this category by a wide margin. It's consistently rated near the top of the category for an excellent all-around combination of ride, traction and treadwear.

Category: On-/Off-Road All-Terrain

Contenders: Goodyear Wrangler SilentArmor vs. Michelin LTX A/T2

Verdict: Michelin's LTX A/T2 squeaks ahead with better balancing, road manners and longevity with traction on loose surfaces. The Goodyear has a more aggressive tread and would be a more popular choice for those who spend more time off the pavement.

Category: Off-Road Maximum Traction

Contenders: Goodyear Wrangler MT/R with Kevlar vs. Michelin (none)

Verdict: The highly capable Goodyear wins this one unopposed.

Roundup: In this very close match-up, Michelin wins two categories, while Goodyear also wins two. These categories were extremely close and selection often come down to a driver's preference.

Tire Rack Consumer Review of the Firestone Destination A/T

Monday, April 29, 2013 by Tire Rack Consumer Reviews

The following post was created from content submitted via Tire Rack's consumer surveys. Information shown is the opinion of the consumer and meant to be used for comparison shopping purposes.

Firestone Destination A/T Reviewer's Overall Rating: 8.88
 
 

2004 Ford F150 XLT Sup Cab 2wd
More Tire Reviews for This Vehicle

 
Buy/More Info
Miles driven on tires: 1,000
Location: Clearwater, FL
Driving Condition: Average

Initial Review, 1,000 Miles on Tires
April 05, 2013

I replaced my Goodyear Wranglers with these tires and so far I am really impressed with them. Mostly the ride comfort and road noise are what I like most. They are very smooth on the highway and quiet too. Only about a thousand mile on them but so far I like them a lot. Will update as tires wear in.

 

Tire Rack Consumer Review of the Goodyear Wrangler DuraTrac

Wednesday, April 24, 2013 by Tire Rack Consumer Reviews

The following post was created from content submitted via Tire Rack's consumer surveys. Information shown is the opinion of the consumer and meant to be used for comparison shopping purposes.

Goodyear Wrangler DuraTrac Reviewer's Overall Rating: 9.36
 
 

1999 Ford F250 4wd Super Duty
More Tire Reviews for This Vehicle

 
Buy/More Info
Miles driven on tires: 5,000
Location: House Springs, MO
Driving Condition: Spirited

Initial Review, 5,000 Miles on Tires
April 15, 2013

Great tires. They look good and they drive great. In snow the width of these tires will track where other tires have been. If your making the trail they will go where ever you want. They do make noise but I expected that when I got them, but its tolerable. Overall a great tire and it will be the only one I put on my Diesel.

 

Tire Rack Consumer Review of the Goodyear Wrangler AT/S

Thursday, April 11, 2013 by Tire Rack Consumer Reviews

The following post was created from content submitted via Tire Rack's consumer surveys. Information shown is the opinion of the consumer and meant to be used for comparison shopping purposes.

Goodyear Wrangler AT/S Reviewer's Overall Rating: 8.13
 
 

2008 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 4wd
More Tire Reviews for This Vehicle

 
Buy/More Info
Miles driven on tires: 73,000
Location: Riverview, FL
Driving Condition: Average

Initial Review, 73,000 Miles on Tires
March 16, 2013

Tires wear evenly when rotated at each oil change.The tires will go another 10,000 miles easy

 

Tire Rack Consumer Review of the Bridgestone Dueler H/L Alenza

Thursday, April 11, 2013 by Tire Rack Consumer Reviews

The following post was created from content submitted via Tire Rack's consumer surveys. Information shown is the opinion of the consumer and meant to be used for comparison shopping purposes.

Bridgestone Dueler H/L Alenza Reviewer's Overall Rating: 7.75
 
 

2006 Land Rover LR3 HSE
More Tire Reviews for This Vehicle

 
Buy/More Info
Miles driven on tires: 9,000
Location: Miami, FL
Driving Condition: Easy Going

Initial Review, 9,000 Miles on Tires
February 17, 2013

This was a replacement tire for the original OEM Goodyears that I replaced at just over 38,000 miles. To be honest I did not know what to expect as these replacement Bridgestones were around half the price of the OEM Goodyears. I was very suprised overall and continue to be with the wet braking performance in particular. They balanced up easily and the ride comfort is excellent. Although maybe not so off road capable as the original Goodyear Wranglers? they do have the same load rating. There is very little wear so far and it is uniform, I would not be suprised if these tires went welll over 40,000 too early to say of course! A very well balanced tire performance wise - in fact a delightful tire and made in USA! If you are mostly on-road do not hesitate to install these on your Land Rover or Range Rover!

 

Tire Rack Consumer Review of the Goodyear Wrangler SilentArmor

Thursday, April 11, 2013 by Tire Rack Consumer Reviews

The following post was created from content submitted via Tire Rack's consumer surveys. Information shown is the opinion of the consumer and meant to be used for comparison shopping purposes.

Goodyear Wrangler SilentArmor Reviewer's Overall Rating: 9.15
 
 

2004 Ford Ranger Sup 2wd XLT
More Tire Reviews for This Vehicle

 
Buy/More Info
Miles driven on tires: 80,000
Location: Laddonia, MO
Driving Condition: Average

Initial Review, 80,000 Miles on Tires
March 13, 2013

I have went 80,000 miles on these tires with no problems. The mechanic at the dealership that changes my oil just now said my tires are starting to show wear. I laughed and said they should after 5 years and 80,000 miles he couldn't believe it he said they looked like about 20,000 mile on them.

 

Tire Rack Consumer Review of the Goodyear Wrangler AT/S

Monday, April 1, 2013 by Tire Rack Consumer Reviews

The following post was created from content submitted via Tire Rack's consumer surveys. Information shown is the opinion of the consumer and meant to be used for comparison shopping purposes.

Goodyear Wrangler AT/S Reviewer's Overall Rating: 8.4
 
 

2004 Ford F150 LariatSupCrw4wd
More Tire Reviews for This Vehicle

 
Buy/More Info
Miles driven on tires: 34,000
Location: Hugo, OK
Driving Condition: Average

Initial Review, 34,000 Miles on Tires
March 29, 2013

This is my 2nd set of identical tires for my Supercrew. The original set came on it from the factory and lasted in the neighborhood of 65,000 miles - there was still life left but I was going on a trip so I went ahead and replaced them. This 2nd set has been equally great tires. My truck now has a little over 99,000 miles and the tires are in great shape. I fully expect the tires to last until I buy a new truck in a couple years. I would absolutely recommend these tires! And I would buy another set in I needed too! Fantastic wear!

 

Tire Rack Consumer Review of the Goodyear Wrangler SilentArmor

Monday, April 1, 2013 by Tire Rack Consumer Reviews

The following post was created from content submitted via Tire Rack's consumer surveys. Information shown is the opinion of the consumer and meant to be used for comparison shopping purposes.

Goodyear Wrangler SilentArmor Reviewer's Overall Rating: 9.27
 
 

2007 Dodge Durango SXT 4wd
More Tire Reviews for This Vehicle

 
Buy/More Info
Miles driven on tires: 50,000
Location: Lake Hopatcong, NJ
Driving Condition: Spirited

Initial Review, 50,000 Miles on Tires
March 30, 2013

I have had these tires on my truck for 2 years and 50,000 miles on them. I still have plenty of tread on them left. I should be able to get 75,000 miles no problem. I think these tires are great. I like how the sidewall sticks out slightly more then the rims to protect them. I would put this tire in the "buy" category

 

Tire Rack Consumer Review of the Goodyear Wrangler DuraTrac

Tuesday, March 26, 2013 by Tire Rack Consumer Reviews

The following post was created from content submitted via Tire Rack's consumer surveys. Information shown is the opinion of the consumer and meant to be used for comparison shopping purposes.

Goodyear Wrangler DuraTrac Reviewer's Overall Rating: 8.08
 
 

1995 Jeep Grand Cherokee Laredo
More Tire Reviews for This Vehicle

 
Buy/More Info
Miles driven on tires: 1,000
Location: Wichita, KS
Driving Condition: Spirited

Initial Review, 1,000 Miles on Tires
March 17, 2013

Only had for around 1K miles but thought I would review anyway. Absolutely OUTSTANDING on snow and ice, I bought these to replace my Goodyear MTR's right before we got 12" of snow, there is no comparison. On packed, snowy roads, it feels SOLID.

As far as off-road tires go, these are definitely a winner. Not as good in mud as the Goodyear MTR's but still very good, and MUCH quieter as well. I don't even notice them on the highway, WAY quieter than the MTR's, but that may change once they have a few thousand miles on them (it usually does).

Outstanding wet traction as well. I haven't had these for long, but if you asked me now if I would buy them again, the answer would be YES.

 

Tire Rack Consumer Review of the Goodyear Wrangler MT/R with Kevlar

Monday, March 25, 2013 by Tire Rack Consumer Reviews

The following post was created from content submitted via Tire Rack's consumer surveys. Information shown is the opinion of the consumer and meant to be used for comparison shopping purposes.

Goodyear Wrangler MT/R with Kevlar Reviewer's Overall Rating: 7.67
 
 

2001 Chevrolet Silverado 4wd
More Tire Reviews for This Vehicle

 
Buy/More Info
Miles driven on tires: 5,000
Location: Detroit Lakes, MN
Driving Condition: Average

Initial Review, 5,000 Miles on Tires
March 19, 2013

I live in minnesota and i have not had these tires on my truck that long. But i have found they are dang good tires in the snow for a "mud tire" i have not tried them out yet in the mud just because i put them on in the middle of winter so far the tread wearin gis good havent had them long enough to tell only about 8000 miles.

 

Tire Rack Consumer Review of the Goodyear Wrangler SR-A

Monday, March 18, 2013 by Tire Rack Consumer Reviews

The following post was created from content submitted via Tire Rack's consumer surveys. Information shown is the opinion of the consumer and meant to be used for comparison shopping purposes.

Goodyear Wrangler SR-A Reviewer's Overall Rating: 5.67
 
 

2013 Ford F150 4wd
More Tire Reviews for This Vehicle

 
Buy/More Info
Miles driven on tires: 6,400
Location:  
Driving Condition: Average

Initial Review, 6,400 Miles on Tires
March 17, 2013

O.E. tires on my 2013 F150 275/65/18. Tires are not good at all. Sidewall flex, poor snow traction, very poor ice traction. Have to use 4wd in situations I shouldn't. Ford has a habbit of putting tires on their vehicles that don't fit the vehicle. All the O.E. tires are poor for the vehicles they put them on. Will be replacing these tires and wheels with 305/45/22 Fortera SL and selling the O.E. setup very soon.

 

FAQ - Mud-Terrain Tires

Wednesday, March 13, 2013 by Gary Stanley

What are mud-terrain tires ?

Mud-terrain tires feature aggressive, heavy blocked tread patterns designed for off-road use in deep mud, rocks and uneven terrain. These tires are often produced in large sizes with reinforced heavy-duty construction. They fall into the Off-Road Maximum Traction category in our customer survey data. 

What kind of drivers use mud-terrain tires?

Drivers who purchase mud-terrain tires range from off-road enthusiasts to those who simply want a more aggressive looking tire for cosmetic appearance. 

Can mud-terrain tires be driven on the street?

Yes, all mud-terrain tires sold at Tire Rack are street legal and can be safely driven on the street and at highway speeds. Keep in mind, if the vast majority of your driving is on the street, you may be better suited choosing a tire in our On-/Off-Road All-Terrain category.  You can view a couple of our top all-terrain tires by reading "BFGoodrich All-Terrain T/A KO vs. Michelin LTX-A/T 2."

How long do mud-terrain tires last?

Treadwear on mud-terrain tires can vary quite a bit depending on driving style, driving conditions, vehicle set-up and other factors. Average on a vehicle that's not heavily modified is about 40,000 miles of mixed off-road and street driving.

What are the disadvantages of using aggressive mud-terrain tires? 

As you might guess, the more aggressive tread patterns of mud tires make more road noise than an all-terrain or highway street tire. Most mud-terrain tires also use heavy-duty construction methods that include thicker and more numerous sidewall plys. While this increases abrasion resistance, the reinforcement can make for a firm ride. The large blocky tread patterns of most these tires lack smaller tread blocks and sipes that are needed for good snow and ice traction. As a result, better snow and ice traction can usually be found with an all-terrain tire or dedicated winter / snow option.

What are some popular mud-terrain tires?

Below are a few options of Off-Road Maximum Traction tires we carry:

Two of the most popular choices are the BFGoodrich Mud-Terrain T/A KM2 and Goodyear Wrangler MT/R with Kevlar. 

 BFGoodrich Mud-Terrain T/A KM2
BFGoodrich Mud-Terrain T/A KM2
 Goodyear Wrangler MT/R with Kevlar
Goodyear Wrangler MT/R with Kevlar


Many off-road enthusiasts install suspension lifts, fender flares and other modifications to allow for larger tire sizes than are typically used on a non-modified vehicle. As a result, it is often more helpful to shop by size

 

Tire Rack Consumer Review of the Kumho Road Venture SAT KL61

Wednesday, March 13, 2013 by Tire Rack Consumer Reviews

The following post was created from content submitted via Tire Rack's consumer surveys. Information shown is the opinion of the consumer and meant to be used for comparison shopping purposes.


Kumho Road Venture SAT KL61Reviewer's Overall Rating: Not Rated

1996 Ford Explorer
More Tire Reviews for This Vehicle


Buy/More Info
Miles driven on tires: 1,200
Location: Indianapolis, IN
Driving Condition: Average

Initial Review, 1,200 Miles on Tires
January 06, 2013

I have a pair of these on the rear axle (Walmart Goodyear Wrangler Radials on front axle) of my 2WD Explorer. We got 7" of snow day after Christmas and five more inches a couple nights later. I had to get into our self-storage place and it hadn't been plowed. I had no issue plowing through the deep stuff. Got hung up occasionally in some big drifts but just backed off and gave it some onion and these babies dug right in to keep me moving.
The sidewalls on these tires have stylish ribs to help get through the snow and they pay off. I highly recommend these to anyone in the market for a good AT tire to help in the snow if you aren't wanting to hassle changing to a "winter specific" tire.

Tire Rack Consumer Review of the Goodyear Wrangler DuraTrac

Wednesday, March 6, 2013 by Tire Rack Consumer Reviews

The following post was created from content submitted via Tire Rack's consumer surveys. Information shown is the opinion of the consumer and meant to be used for comparison shopping purposes.

Goodyear Wrangler DuraTrac Reviewer's Overall Rating: 9.75
 
 

2010 Chevrolet Colorado LT Crew Cab
More Tire Reviews for This Vehicle

 
Buy/More Info
Miles driven on tires: 22,500
Location: Olathe, KS
Driving Condition: Spirited

Initial Review, 22,500 Miles on Tires
February 26, 2013

By far the best tire for snow I have ever had. I wanted a knobby tire that was good in mud and off-road but still gave me good snow traction, this tire is it. I will never buy a different type of tire.

 

Tire Rack Consumer Review of the Pirelli Scorpion ATR

Thursday, February 28, 2013 by Tire Rack Consumer Reviews

The following post was created from content submitted via Tire Rack's consumer surveys. Information shown is the opinion of the consumer and meant to be used for comparison shopping purposes.


Pirelli Scorpion ATRReviewer's Overall Rating: 9.17

2013 Land Rover Discovery 4
More Tire Reviews for This Vehicle


Buy/More Info
Miles driven on tires: 38,000
Location: Johannesburg, SA
Driving Condition: Average

Initial Review, 38,000 Miles on Tires
February 06, 2013

I've had these tires for 38000 miles and they look almost new. They were an massive upgrade to the standard Goodyear Wranglers that came stock with the vehicle.
Besides a couple of punctures (about 4 now) right through the main tread, these tires are nothing short of brilliant. Very highly recommended.

Tire Rack Consumer Review of the Goodyear Wrangler SR-A

Thursday, February 28, 2013 by Tire Rack Consumer Reviews

The following post was created from content submitted via Tire Rack's consumer surveys. Information shown is the opinion of the consumer and meant to be used for comparison shopping purposes.

Goodyear Wrangler SR-A Reviewer's Overall Rating: 7.17
 
 

2009 Dodge Ram 1500 SLT 4wd
More Tire Reviews for This Vehicle

 
Buy/More Info
Miles driven on tires: 46,000
Location:  
Driving Condition: Average

Initial Review, 46,000 Miles on Tires
February 23, 2013

These OEMs on my Ram 1500 have been better than most OEMs on other vehicles. At 46k I have been commuting 35 miles in messy midwest snow conditions. Handling is good to very good in snow (esp. with 4WD on). Confident handling while towing also. Ride is smoother than I expected - I get compliments on my truck's ride and handling, tires get partial credit. May buy another set, just now looking.

 

Tire Rack Consumer Review of the Goodyear Wrangler SilentArmor

Thursday, February 28, 2013 by Tire Rack Consumer Reviews

The following post was created from content submitted via Tire Rack's consumer surveys. Information shown is the opinion of the consumer and meant to be used for comparison shopping purposes.

Goodyear Wrangler SilentArmor Reviewer's Overall Rating: 8.86
 
 

1993 Ford Bronco
More Tire Reviews for This Vehicle

 
Buy/More Info
Miles driven on tires: 30,000
Location: Portsmouth, VA
Driving Condition: Average

Initial Review, 30,000 Miles on Tires
February 25, 2013

These are great tires. In fact, they are the best all terrain tire I've ever used. They go like stink in sugar sand, as long as you air down to 18-20PSI in 4HI. They laugh at fire roads, gravel, shale, and even wet grass and offer extremely responsive steering. Broncos have short wheel bases, and these tires have transformed my truck into a "corner carver". They are ABSOLUTELY SILENT. Even after 30,000 miles, they remain silent and evenly worn, unlike a lot of all-terrain tires. Because most of my off-road excursions include sand driving, I need a tire that guarantees I don't get stuck. I have NEVER been stuck with these. One word of caution, though (an I find their name to be a bit of a misnomer): They are not indestructable. Although they offer great proetection against puncture, their sidewalls will quickly get trashed if you rub curbs, as with most passenger car tires. Some "side biters" or sidewall protection would be nice, as I live in the real world, and not on the sand dunes. The other major advantage to these tires is their light weight, which reduces unsprung weight, increases power to the ground, and increases fuel economy. I have ended my search with these tires, and will be installing a set on another truck of mine shortly.

 

Tire Rack Consumer Review of the Goodyear Wrangler DuraTrac

Thursday, February 28, 2013 by Tire Rack Consumer Reviews

The following post was created from content submitted via Tire Rack's consumer surveys. Information shown is the opinion of the consumer and meant to be used for comparison shopping purposes.

Goodyear Wrangler DuraTrac Reviewer's Overall Rating: 9.08
 
 

2006 Volkswagen Jetta TDI 1.9L
More Tire Reviews for This Vehicle

 
Buy/More Info
Miles driven on tires: 3,500
Location:  
Driving Condition: Average

Initial Review, 3,500 Miles on Tires
February 23, 2013

ON MY 2006 FORD F350 CC DRW 4 WD DIESEL. I WENT OLD SCHOOL AND WITH THE HELP OF THE TIRE RACK CUSTOMER SERVICE STAFF( THANK LESLIE AND ALEX) I MATCHES 4 DURA TRAC REAR AND 2 WRANGLER FRONTS. YES THEY INITIALLY WERE UNSURE OF MY DECISION HOWEVER THE DECISION WAS MY RESPONSIBILITY. MY TRUCK CAME WITH GOODRICH TA'S. THE WERE NICE DRY ROAD TIRES BUT ANY MUD OR SNOW AND THEY BECAME SLICKS. MY COMBO HAS CHANGED THE DYNAMICS OF THIS TRUCK AND ALLOWS ME MORE NON 4WD USE ON MARGINAL ROADS, SAVING FUEL. THANKS AGAIN TIRERACK

 

Tire Rack Consumer Review of the Pirelli Scorpion ATR

Tuesday, February 26, 2013 by Tire Rack Consumer Reviews

The following post was created from content submitted via Tire Rack's consumer surveys. Information shown is the opinion of the consumer and meant to be used for comparison shopping purposes.


Pirelli Scorpion ATRReviewer's Overall Rating: 7.64

2006 Land Rover LR3 HSE
More Tire Reviews for This Vehicle


Buy/More Info
Miles driven on tires: 25,000
Location: 98045, WA
Driving Condition: Spirited

Initial Review, 25,000 Miles on Tires
February 19, 2013

I have two LR3 HSE's and a LR4, The Pirelli was definitely a better choice than the original equipment Goodyear Wranglers that flat spotted and wore out early. Pirelli's are a great all around tire and work well both on Forest service trails and on the highway. They are quiet for the versatile tread design and long wearing. Highly Recommended.

Tire Rack Consumer Review of the BFGoodrich Mud-Terrain T/A KM

Monday, February 25, 2013 by Tire Rack Consumer Reviews

The following post was created from content submitted via Tire Rack's consumer surveys. Information shown is the opinion of the consumer and meant to be used for comparison shopping purposes.

BFGoodrich Mud-Terrain T/A KM Reviewer's Overall Rating: 8.27
 
 

2013 Jeep Wrangler Unlimited
More Tire Reviews for This Vehicle

 
Buy/More Info
Miles driven on tires: 3,500
Location: Goshen, IN
Driving Condition: Spirited

Initial Review, 3,500 Miles on Tires
February 24, 2013

Excellent street-able mud tire, good wear if you keep them rotated and monitor pressure. They cut through deep snow like they are heated. Good self-cleaning characteristics in deep mud, like most other tires, they cake up in deep/wet heavy clay.

Note regarding other reviews: Ignore idiots that can't spell, type in all CAPS and put "C" load range tires on 3/4 & 1 ton pickups. Consider the source.

I've had multiple sets of BFG M/T on vehicles and they've never let me down. If you get stuck with these you either don't know how to drive, or were doing something stupid. If you're experiencing poor wear (and are marginally smart enough to run appropriate pressure and rotate frequently), your junk vehicle probably needs suspension work. If you like Chevy's and Goodyear M/Ts... well, I can't help you, cause you can't fix stupid.